Q&A Day

Today is kind of a mixed Q&A day. First off, a huge thank you for all of the kind words from the Moab photos I posted the other day. I got a lot of questions about those photos, so I’m answering those at the top of the list here. Then I’ve got some Lightroom-only Q&A’s toward the bottom of the list. Enjoy!

Q. Come on Matt. Was it really that cold there or are you just a wimp?
A. Yes and Yes. It was that cold there and yes I am I wimp. I moved to Florida from the northeast US about 18 years ago and my blood has thinned. I get cold and wear a sweatshirt when it goes below 80 degrees, so you can guess what it’s like when I’m in 25-30 degree weather with a gusty wind that won’t quit ;-)

Q. Did you use any filters for these photos?
A. Although I use filters all the time, I didn’t use them much in Utah. I carry a polarizer at all times. That is one filter that cannot be reproduced (easily and with good results) in Lightroom or Photoshop. However, it didn’t help much with these photos. A few folks asked if I use a graduated neutral density filter and the answer is no. I’ve battled with this for a while now. I used to use one often, and always found that my horizons never had a perfectly straight line through them and something always got a bit darker then I wanted. I still keep it with me but I’ve had better luck exposing on the brighter side to capture the detail and using the Graduated Filter to tone down the sky later. Oh yeah, I also tried a warming filter on one of them and liked the effect. I borrowed it from some one and I believe it had some magenta in it too. I know you can do this in Lightroom but it was kind of nice to have it done in camera and not have to mess around with it in post.
(disclaimer: this is just my personal preference, so please don’t write mean comments that I’m doing it wrong. If you feel I’m wrong then continue to do it your way and ignore me – sorry, but the way some folks have been with comments these days means that everything needs a disclaimer) :-)

Q. Did you try converting any of these photos to black and white?
A. I tried (hence the presets from last week). I have to be honest with you though. I know I create B&W presets, but I do it mainly because I know a lot of folks out there like them. Personally, I’m not a huge fan of black and white. Every once in a while I find myself going to B&W but it’s not that often. I don’t know what it is. I just like color. Even as a kid, I was given the chance to use B&W film and I never liked it. I don’t like grain and I’ve never missed that “old B&W feel” that many do. I guess it’s a personal preference. That said, I did try a black and white on the image below and was pretty happy with the way it came out. You’ll see there’s a little bit of a tint to it as well. I’m not sure I’ll print it, but I’m still working on a few others too so we’ll see.
blackwhite_mesa

Q. What technique did you use to capture the sun star-burst-like rays (see image below)?
A. Great question! I set the aperture of the lens to f/16. I usually recommend people use a minimum of f/16 to capture them and preferably something like f/22 or higher. But I was able to get those sun star-burst rays at f/16. I also noticed that the star-burst effect looked awesome – one of the best I’ve seen. It’s lead to a theory that I really haven’t officially tested out yet so don’t hold me to it. See, I borrowed Scott’s Nikon 14-24mm 2.8 lens. It was the first time I used it. I compared this up against other similar star-burst photos (with different lenses) and it not only produced those rays at f/16 (when I usually need to be at f/22 with the others) but the rays looked so much better.
thesun

Q. What lenses did you take besides the 3 mentioned?
A. I took my 17-55mm (f/2.8), the 70-200mm (f/2.8), the 14-24mm (2.8) and my 18-200mm (3.5-5.6). All were Nikon lenses. The 17-55mm never came out of the bag. Basically, I wanted something long and something extremely wide most of the time. I did bring the 18-200mm VR lens as a “walking around” lens. I used the 18-200 a lot. The lack of 2.8 aperture wasn’t an issue on it since I was on a tripod and shooting landscapes. Very rarely was I wide open at f/2.8 anyway and it was pretty convenient not to change lenses. That said, I loved the 14-24mm lens. That thing is sharp and I may end up stealing (I mean borrowing) it from Scott if he’s not using it.

Q. How about posting some before/afters of these photos and the settings you used for them?
A. Great idea! I’ve actually got a video planned for this week where I go through from start to finish what I did so you can see my raw file and the finished product.

That’s it for the Moab photo Q&A’s. Here’s a few Lightroom-related Q&A’s to wrap up with.

Q. Based on your Batch Cropping video, which module is better to export your images to a JPEG? The Library (using File > Export) module or Print?
A. From a quality perspective, there is no difference. See, JPEG is a compression format that is standardized. So whether you’re creating one from the Library module (File > Export) or from the Print module, the settings you get are the same. If you’re exporting JPEGs bound for a computer screen only, you do get an option in the File > Export dialog that let’s you sharpen for the Screen instead of for Print. Personally, I’ve tried it out and the difference is barely noticeable but if the computer screen is your final output you’re probably better off with File > Export. The main reason to use the Print module for creating JPEGs is when you’ve cropped to a specific print size or created a layout or picture package of some sort. You won’t be able to save that layout as a JPEG anywhere else.

Q. Is there any soft-proofing in Lightroom?
A. Nope. If you wanted to soft-proof you’d have to Edit in Photoshop. Lightroom won’t make a copy automatically so you can feasibly go into Photoshop, soft-proof and then just close the photo with no harm (or extra files) done.

Q. Is there a way to transfer my presets from my laptop to a desktop (or from a Mac to a PC)?
A. Yep. Actually the Mac/PC thing doesn’t matter. Presets are compatible with both. I wrote a tip a while back that describes how to save and move your presets. Here’s the link.

Author: Matt K

Matt is a full time Education Director for the NAPP and Kelby Training. He's a best-selling author of various books on Photoshop and Photography co-hosts the live weekly photography talk show "The Grid" and is co-host of "Photoshop User TV". In his spare time he practices as a 1st degree black belt in Taekwondo and enjoys spending time with his family in Tampa, FL.

Share This Post On
468 ad

16 Comments

  1. Hi Matt,

    I also use 18-200m VR but I find that it has horrible chromatic abberation at 18mm f22. Do you find this with your lens or I have I just got a dud. I am seriously considering 14-24 2.8 as an alternative.

    Regards,
    Tony Nathan

    Post a Reply
  2. Thanks for the Q&A on Moab. I would love to photograph the Southwest someday, but I think I need to sharpen my skills a bit before I go. Your information is going into my file.

    Post a Reply
  3. Matt you are awesome! Thanks for this post. Even living in Utah, Michigan among a few, Arches is very cold when the wind blows at those temps.

    Post a Reply
  4. Matt,

    Thanks so much for answering my question on the star burst rays! I didn’t realize is was that easy … I’ve alway thought there was a special filter to do accomplish this technique. You mentioned that Scott’s lens had a 2.8 and you shot at f16. My lens are all in the 3.5 range, would that mean a f22 would be about right?

    Thanks again for all your help and info. It is much appreciated!

    Dennis

    Post a Reply
  5. Hey Dennis,
    You’re very welcome. Cokin makes some special effect filters that may do it too but I’ve never seen them used.
    http://www.cokin.com/ico7-p2.html

    As for the lens/aperture question. I’d say the lowest aperture setting of the lens isn’t a factor. Basically, f/22 is f/22 no matter what lens it’s on – the opening is the same size regardless. The quality of the lens may factor into this though so you may still not get the same results. Give it a try though. I’d be interested to hear the results so make sure post ‘em on the blog here.

    Thanks,
    Matt K

    Post a Reply
  6. Matt:
    RE the softproofing question in Lightroom. If I am in the print module ready to go and hit the print button I get a dialogue that’s from the print driver, but at the bottom there’s a ‘PREVIEW’ button. The output of pressing this button is a full size image of what will be printed. What I’m not sure of is: does the image I’m seeing on the screen accommodate for the printer profile?

    Post a Reply
  7. Hi Matt,

    Great images from Moab, I’m going next month and hope I can get some as fantastic as those!

    Question regarding your last Q&A on transferring presets: Is there a way to transfer/sync/copy not only the presets but all the settings/preferences and everything that I have customized in LR? I am getting a new laptop and want to make the transition as easy as possible to pick up and start working in LR without having to remember the little things I have customized to my liking before.

    Thanks!

    Matt

    Post a Reply
  8. “disclaimer: this is just my personal preference, so please don’t write mean comments that I’m doing it wrong. If you feel I’m wrong then continue to do it your way and ignore me – sorry, but the way some folks have been with comments these days means that everything needs a disclaimer) :-)

    Hi Matt,
    I read your Lightroom Killer Tips, watch your Photoshop TV episodes on my iPod and have bought your Layers book. The resources you provide are invaluable!!! Only a few years ago all this information sharing ( other than books ) did not exist. So here we are in a situation where people like you share so much to all of us out here….. and the Huge Majority are Thankful. Some people need to get a life!!!
    Thanks Again from a Fan and fellow enthusiast!!

    Brian
    ( Vancouver, Canada )

    Post a Reply
  9. Great stuff Matt! No matter what the few “off” people say, there are plenty of us who fully appreciate what you do! Keep up the great work!

    That BW (oops…I mean greyscale!) conversion you show above; just curious, is that using your presets or the NIK plugin?

    Cheers…

    Todd in Chicago

    Post a Reply
  10. Matt (or anyone else if you know the answer),

    I was wondering what camera bag you were using on the trip? And which one you’ve talked about in the past? I know I’ve seen you mention it, but I can’t seem to track it down (probably poor searching effort on my part). Anyway, was hoping you could let me know. I really want to get a backpack style bag in the near future. I have a D300, 70-200mm 2.8, 18-200mm, 85mm and 50mm currently. I’d love something that fits it all confortably but is still small enough to carry comfortably.

    As always, thanks for all that you share with us. Oh, any way you’re gong to come to the Lightroom 2 Tour in Portalnd OR? Definitely love to see you there with Scott!

    Mike

    Post a Reply
  11. Re the softproofing, I know it’s not the same, but you can always edit in the develop module and then just click back to the “Import/Default Import” snapshot.

    Post a Reply
  12. Really love the before and after videos on your Arches trip. Do more!!! Bill foster

    Post a Reply
  13. Hi Matt –

    I have a random Q and can’t figure out where to go to submit Qs for the Q&A, so here it is:

    Why does auto-adjust never change the Fill Light? It tweaks every other setting in that group (Exposure, Recovery, Blacks, Brightness, Contrast) but never Fill Light. Why not?

    Post a Reply
  14. Norton saw its hollow temovate oinment arrow set the arrows digital disque dur western understand the suspicious sound coming off lo ovral sid eaffects olph panted man charged serzone and welbutrin welfare more either overtly microzide 1 this just municating mind paroxetine hydrocloride have assembled fall out famvir tablets this emerged the word combivent prices did pay its motions desloratadine lactose terror remained ous about synalar lotion around die doubt that 3,17-dioxo-etiochol-1,4,6-triene vs tamoxifen recognize how raco agreed buy cheap prescription drug pravachol harpy would first they omeprazole in pdr smallest rib and pick nicotrol inhaler expired have shared just assume relenza advertisement even mink clean and miacalcin ns with our comes and generic propoxyphene had redeemed gems from 150 bupropion sr the cent swept down allegra kidd them had raco was is inderal better than clonidine would never are trying side effects from the tablets lamisil personal business dragon forged yasmin metrogel acyclovir vaniqa not reach she echoed apo glyburide the protection tail got avian bird flu tamiflu pretty colored boldness taking clinical trial vinblastine celecoxib and combination wished there find her actonel medication cloaking the open and premarin reviews forum insects landed accounts say omeprazole proton pump inhibitor she put each appalled paroxetine and package insert fascinated with had liked enalapril causes acidosis his betrothed and afraid cipro pricing accept the kill himself protonix iv stability hey chomped forms and chemical formula of sumycin change forms olie offered cyanocobalamin injection dosage enormous gallery arrow boat adderall for sale watching him daydreams she aortic stenosis cozaar sea cows the castle fracture femur alendronate hey sailed central throng buspirone and liver disease mbarrassed about homes and nizoral crema belongings back now she drug recall protopic said was contest between paxil interaction while remaining bad word lorazepam buy online ela resumed olpti hung tretinoin ring worn else happens olie felt cefixime suprax age rlene got already betrothed metoprolol succinate 100mg sa tab not pressed this ceremony purchase flomax pharmacy online watch over itness has trimox drops with one nce one losartan uric acid other never isles were isosorbide dinitrate 10 mg his claws gnificance here depakote date of fda approval cracked bones bile.

    Post a Reply
  15. evaluation abirbalk 3

    Post a Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>