Lightroom 3 Beta Q&A

Here’s some Lightroom 3 Beta Q&A’s for ya:

Q. Will the beta run next to my real version of Lightroom 2? Basically, can I use both?
A. Yep. No problem you can use both at the same time.

Q. Will my Lightroom 2 Catalogs Work with Lightroom 3 Beta?
A. No. You’ll have to import a whole new set of images in order to use the beta. You can’t just open (or export) a LR2 catalog.

Q. If I use the beta will I be able to upgrade to the real version of the software and keep all of my work?
A. That’s where things get tricky. Adobe always recommends that you don’t do any work in the beta that you’re not prepared to eventually lose. It really is just for testing and demo purposes. So there’s no guarantee that the work you do will be portable to the full version of LR3. However, in the past, the catalogs have upgraded but again, that’s not a promise for the future. I always have a hard time with this one because once the beta comes out, I have to be honest with you and say I start using it full time. I know I shouldn’t and I know its bad, but what can I say. Once I get a taste of the new features its no fun to use the old ones anymore. Let’s hope that it does indeed upgrade the catalog from the betas as Lightroom has done before :)

Q. When will the full version of Lightroom 3 actually ship?
A. Adobe isn’t releasing that information right now. In an interview I did with product manager Tom Hogarty, he mentioned that it wouldn’t be as long at the beta period for LR1 (like a year or so) but it wouldn’t be as short as the beta for Lightroom 2 (only a few months). And the software itself has no indication like a “This software expires on October 31, 2009″ or anything like that.

Q. In your movie on the Lightroom Learning Center, you said that the Luminance slider under Noise Reduction was grayed out and not hooked up yet. But I imported some photos and its there. Why?
A. Yeah, the Luminance slider will be grayed out when editing raw files that haven’t been edited before. If you’ve imported a photo into Lightroom that was edited in a previous version of LR or Camera Raw, then Lightroom is applying the old noise removal and sharpening stuff to it. You’ll know this is the case if you go to the Settings > Process Version menu in the Develop module and see “Version 1″. That means its using the old stuff. You’ll have to update to Version 2 to take advantage of the new sharpening and noise removal improvements (and the lack of Luminance slider).

Q. What’s all the hype around the Import dialog? I don’t have any problems importing photos.
A. As an existing Lightroom user I don’t think the Import dialog improvements were really meant for you. If you’ve been using Lightroom, then chances are you know how to import by now. However, an easier Importing process is essential for Lightroom to grow beyond current users to new ones. Its been a little clunky in the past. Those that know it, know it. Those that never used Lightroom will now understand that importing process (hopefully) easier then you did when you were learning.

Q. So Matt, what’s your take on the beta?
A. My take is actually very similar to what Tom Hogarty was saying in the interview I did with him. The beta feels a bit more unrefined to me then previous ones. That’s pretty evident when there’s a slider that doesn’t even work (Noise Removal). For so long people have almost gotten used to the fact that a beta was really close to a shipping version of the software. Adobe’s not saying for sure but they have alluded to the fact that there will be more features coming in the full version. So I think its cool for now. The features that are there are definitely worth trying out, but there’s a handful of features that aren’t there (as many of you pointed out) that I hope make it into the full release. In the short term, the beta is nice but not life-changing. It does whet my appetite for what’s to come which, in the long term, I’m sure will have a bigger change on my everyday workflow in Lightroom.

Author: Matt K

Matt is a full time Education Director for the NAPP and Kelby Training. He's a best-selling author of various books on Photoshop and Photography co-hosts the live weekly photography talk show "The Grid" and is co-host of "Photoshop User TV". In his spare time he practices as a 1st degree black belt in Taekwondo and enjoys spending time with his family in Tampa, FL.

Share This Post On
468 ad

15 Comments

  1. I found it interesting that there was not any mention that Beta 3 is 64 bit capable. Isn’t that really worth a significant upgrade incentive from LR2?

    Post a Reply
  2. Oh Matt, it should WHET (not wet) your appetite! (Nobody’s perfect!)

    Post a Reply
  3. Regarding migrating your beta catalog to the release version of LR3, in the release notes for LR3b (http://labs.adobe.com/technologies/lightroom3/releasenotes.pdf) Adobe states the following: “Lightroom 1.x, 2.x and 3 beta libraries will be able to be migrated to the finished version of Lightroom 3.”

    So that’s comforting, althought they also state: “Develop settings applied in Lightroom 3 beta are not guaranteed to transfer correctly to the final version of Lightroom 3″

    Post a Reply
  4. The added export features within the Slideshow Module are very promising, but I can’t figure out how to select more than 1 song, which is very straight forward in Lightroom 2. Where am I going wrong?

    Post a Reply
  5. Dear sirs, i have a problem in LR3. I can´t open the picture in Photoshop CS4. Can yuo help me ?

    Post a Reply
  6. HD video just option to add 1 mp3. Contrary to Photoshop Elements no possibility for start/stop position, fit to mp3, etc.
    HD video burned to DVD, doesn’t play music fluently.
    Import is more difficult, at least for me as an advanced user.
    In fact I do not see great advantages comparing with LR2. Also the noise reduction gives the same result when I correct a photo in LR2 and LR3.

    Post a Reply
  7. What?? I can’t import my 175,000 image catalog. What is Adobe thinking?

    Post a Reply
  8. How can it be that I can’t just open (or export) a LR2 catalog!? What about all my collections and photo adjustments?

    Post a Reply
  9. LR2 runs in 64-bit mode on Win7 / Vista as well.

    Post a Reply
  10. You people complaining that existing light room catalogues cannot be imported to LR3 beta are missing the point – the beta exists as a test bed for the new product – thousands of beta users find problems quicker than Adobes engineers. It is not intended to be a fully functioning product – it could have bugs etc – you dont want to put your “175,000 image catalog” in a beta program that may contain flaws. If it was a fully rounded ready for market product that did everything you wanted, youd be paying for it!

    Post a Reply
  11. To Rogan: >>you dont want to put your “175,000 image catalog” in a beta program that may contain flaws…
    The purpose of beta program is to discover bugs. Importing a “175,000 image catalog” is a good way to test the program in real-world conditions IMHO. After all, you’ll always have your LR2 catalog untouched in case of LR3 crashes.

    Post a Reply
  12. Hello.

    I have a question for you. I do not own any version of Lightroom (I have Elements however). I do have the trial version of Lightroom 2, and the Beta of Lightroom up and operating however.

    I love Lightroom (as opposed to using iPhoto) and will most certainly be buying it.

    Here’s the question.

    IYHO, should I simply use the Beta as my main program till it expires then buy Lightroom 3, or should I purchase Lightroom 2 and upgrade when the time comes?

    I do not want to loose all my edits (I will back up the originals of course), so I hesitate to use the Beta as my main program.

    I’m pretty low volume on pictures (family, sporting events, scenery, HDR, etc), processing maybe (thinking….) between 1000-2000 photos a month. Give or take, depending on how much time I have on hand.

    I know there are no guarantees with a Beta, period. But if you were me, what would you do?

    Thanks.

    Post a Reply
  13. Do you have any idea if LR3 can be used with non-Intel Macs like a G5? Also, will I be able to upgrade from LR1 directly to LR3?

    Post a Reply
  14. I am new to LR3, and I am looking for a detailed instructions as how I get music from Itunes into the the slide show section of LR3. Please advise.

    Post a Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>